Alicia D'amore wrote:
crag630 wrote:
I was not being harsh or trying to offend anyone just wondering.
It came across as harsh. Ask yourself this - if someone said they were a size 16 (a size that on certain frames can be considered overweight even if it isn't on all people just as the same can be said of a size 6 being underweight) would you question their weight?
I don't really understand how you came to the question "is that a healthy weight?" when the OP hadn't mentioned their weight?
I'm not trying to have a go at all - but I feel it important to challenge people on things like this because we're supposed to be an open and welcoming forum and I think posts like that can actually do a lot more harm than you'd realise - by my mentioning of it, I hope that you might be able to consider the potential damage if it ever comes up again :) some women are very sensitive of their weight and can do little to change it and since many people think all slender women choose to be that way so they do tend to get slated in the media, by strangers, by their friends. It can leave many (of which I know of at least two on this forum not counting myself) women, very, very insecure and feeling like they have to justify to everyone they know how much they eat etc.
Sorry if this is a bit ranty, I don't mean to come across negatively, just hope I can shed a little light and encourage people to think from a different perspective
Adx
Its was as I mentioned not intended too up set anyone and I understand perfectly well some people have weight issue's but I was enquiring as to weather the weight due to the afore mentioned size does not sound healthy too me personnaly going purely on what I know it just doesnt sound healthy.
As for questoning somone who said they were size 16 well I don't know enough to make a decission on that one as I only really know as far as women and men too come to think of it size 4-6 sounds from an uneducated point of view dangerously slim!
However now I know that it can be a healthy weight.
Have to disagree that some can do little to change their weight though unless you are refering to medical reasons?
I can only say again I intended to upset no one.