Need a good toy idea

My boyfriend (I'm a guy) wants to find a good toy to use on me multiple times before getting a new one to use on me.  I love when he fills me up with the real thing, but I love letting him have his way with me and he loves it too.  But what is the best toy that feels great.  He usually uses about a 7.5- 9 inch toy on me.  He's 9.5... I don't think I want a toy bigger than him as I might like it too much.  So any ideas would be appreciated.

A gay friend of mine told me he always goes for G-Spot vibes because if you turn them round he said they stimulate his P-Spot.

Here are the G-Spot Vibes

http://www.lovehoney.co.uk/sex-toys/vibrators/g-spot-vibrators/

I've never used it in my ass but I'd recommend this one for strength of vibrations & the texture of it and it's about the length you're looking for

http://www.lovehoney.co.uk/product.cfm?p=16030

Good luck - hope you find something you both enjoy

CCW x

 Hi ToyLover, there's no one consensus on the "best" toy, it all depends on your own tastes and preferences really! The ones CurlyCoupleWife mentioned are a good place to start though :)

I just wanted to say that it doesn't matter how big the toy, nothing compares to the feeling of your partner! I have a couple of toys that are bigger than my partner's penis, and I'd still choose him over them any day, any time. Don't worry about liking a toy "too much"!!